Book Review:

The Age of Spiritual Machines

By Tim Condon, Tampa PC Users Group
tim@free-market.net


brain2.jpg (23064 bytes)

Attention all inhabitants of Earth: This is a message for all human beings, including those of you who are members of the Tampa Bay PC Users Group in Tampa, Florida. There is something you should be aware of: The human species is going to go extinct, and that will happen relatively soon, probably within the next few hundred years. It’s not that we’re all going to die at the same time. It’s that within the next 100 years most people, if not everyone, will voluntarily merge into the intelligent machines that are even now being planned and created, resulting in what will arguably be a new species.

At least that’s what well-known scientist, author and inventor Ray Kurzweil postulates in his book, recently out in trade paperback, The Age of Spiritual Machines. Yes, I know, it sounds like just so much mumbo-jumbo baloney, on the same level as the predictions 50 years ago that we’d all be commuting to work in helicopters today. But Kurzweil deals with such skepticism, and draws upon an extremely good record in predicting the future of technology to bolster his vision.

Many of us in the TPCUG remember quite clearly the dawn of the "microcomputer" revolution. It happened, if any event like that can be specifically pinned down, in 1981 when the IBM-PC was introduced. Prior to that everyone was fiddling with Apple II’s and Texas Instrument TI-88's (was that it?), and Altairs, and Commodores, and various computer operating systems, mostly CP/M. Of course, the stodgy, backward business world resisted all along, regarding microcomputers as mere "toys"...until IBM came out with its Personal Computer, whereupon the new "micro"computer was "validated", and the revolution began in earnest.

That revolution has been driven by the inexorable march of "Moore’s Law." Gordon Moore, an inventor of the integrated circuit and in 1965 the chairman of Intel Corporation, postulated then that the number of switches (transistors, if you will) that could be placed onto the face of a silicon wafer would double about every twelve months. In 1975 he is said to have increased the timeline to "every 18 months" (although Kurzweil notes that Moore today says that "his 1975 update was to twenty-four months, and that does appear to be a better fit to the data").

So far no insurmountable obstacles have been encountered to the continuation of Moore’s Law. But Kurzweil notes that chip companies only have confidence that the process can continue for about another 15 to 20 years, when "the paradigm will break down. The transistor insulators will then be just a few atoms thick, and the conventional approach of shrinking them won’t work."

"What then?" Kurzweil asks.

He spends a considerable portion of his book explaining "what then." And explaining why the continued exponential growth of computing power won’t hit a brick wall as expected around 2018 (think quantum computers for starts). If he’s right, the result will be the creation of machines with computing power billions of times more powerful than the human brain, and, ultimately, the merging of human intelligence with machine (or "artificial") intelligence.

Mere science fiction? Kurzweil, who is the inventor of the music synthesizer, reading machines for the blind, and a leading variant of speech-recognition technology, was named Inventor of the Year in 1988 by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. In addition, Carnegie Mellon University awarded him its top science prize in 1994. He’s not a nut case. And, in fact, he has an enviable record of correctly predicting the future over the past 20 or so years (which he goes over in the book).

What he predicts now—in fact, postulates as "an inexorable emergence"—is the imminent arrival of machine intelligence superior to human intelligence:

In the second decade of the next century [that is, from 2011 to 2020], it will become increasingly difficult to draw any clear distinction between the capabilities of human and machine intellgence. The advantages of computer intelligence in terms of speed, accuracy, and capacity will be clear. The advantages of human intelligence, on the other hand, will become increasingly difficult to distinguish....Before the next century is over, human beings will no longer be the most intelligent or capable type of entity on the planet.

Kurzweil is so sure of his predictions that he includes a detailed timeline, handing over the last five chapters of his book to explicit scenarios that he sees emerging in 1999, 2009, 2019, 2029, and finally what the world will look like in 2099. He postulates that by about 2020 a computer that can be purchased with $1,000 of today’s dollars will have the computing power of a single human brain. Then...well, here’s what he says:

After human capacity in a $1,000 personal computer is achieved around the year 2020, our thinking machines will improve the cost performance of their computing by a factor of two every twelve months. That means that the capacity of computing will double ten times every decade, which is a factor of one thousand (210) every ten years. So your personal computer will be able to simulate the brain power of a small village by the year 2030, the entire population of the United States by 2048, and a trillion human brains by 2060. If we estimate the human Earth population at 10 billion persons, one penny’s worth of computing circa 2099 will have a billion times greater computing capacity than all humans on Earth.

I know, I know, it’s incredible (i.e. "not credible") and beyond belief, and there are all kinds of arguments to throw in Kurzweil’s face. We all know about the current limitations of computers and computing, and it seems reasonable that it’s going to be more than a little hard to overcome hurdles in the future to attaining the kind of computing power Kurzweil is talking about. Yet he’s an acknowledged expert in the area, active in computing and invention for over 20 years and making spot-on predictions through the whole time.

There are two concepts which Kurzweil argues are driving the evolution of humans and machines: The Law of Time and Chaos and The Law of Accelerating Returns. The definition of the Law of Time and Chaos is this: "In a process, the time interval between salient events (that is, events that change the nature of the process, or significantly affect the future of the process) expands or contracts along with the amount of chaos." A further definition of "chaos" is needed: "It refers to the quantity of disordered (that is, random) events that are relevant to the process....If we’re dealing with the process of evolution of life-forms, then chaos represents the unpredictable events encountered by organisms, and the random mutations that are introduced in the genetic code."

The next Law postulated by Kurzweil, which he says is the opposite of the Law of Time and Chaos, "is the most important and relevant for our purposes." This "inverse sublaw" to the Law of Time and Chaos is "the Law of Accelerating Returns." Definition? "As order exponentially increases, time exponentially speeds up (that is, the time interval between salient events grows shorter as time passes)." Thus, "The Law of Accelerating Returns...applies specifically to evolutionary processes. In an evolutionary process, it is order—the opposite of chaos—that is increasing."

But wait! Surely Kurzweil isn’t arguing that biological evolution itself is "speeding up"! Well...yes, he does make that argument. Evolution has one huge deficiency, he notes:

[It] is very slow. While it is true that it has created some remarkable designs, it has taken an extremely long period of time to do so. It took eons for the process to get started, and, for the evolution of life-forms, eons meant billions of years. Our human forebears also took eons to get started in their creation of technology, but for us eons meant only tens of thousands of years, a distinct improvement.

The Law of Accelerating Returns also suggests that evolution will devise a way to bypass itself. That is, it evolves intelligence (namely, us) which is capable of devising intelligence (namely computers) that surpasses itself. Furthermore, says Kurzweil, the Law of Accelerating Returns "predicts that the progression in the capabilities of human-created machines will only continue to accelerate. The human species creating intelligent technology is another example of evolution’s progress building on itself. Evolution created human intelligence. Now human intelligence is designing intelligent machines at a far faster pace."

In fact, Kurzweil argues that normal biological evolution will eventually have to be scrapped altogether by humans. Consider the human brain, the most complex object known in the universe, a crowning achievement of billions of years of biological evolution. Says Kurzweil:

The human brain is eminently capable in some ways, and remarkably weak in others. Its strength is reflected in its massive parallelism, an approach that our computers can also benefit from. The brain’s weakness is the extraordinarily slow speed of its computing medium, a limitation that computers do not share with us. For this reason, DNA-based evolution will eventually have to be abandoned. DNA-based evolution is good at tinkering with and extending its designs, but it is unable to scrap an entire design and start over. Organisms created through DNA-based evolution are stuck with an extremely plodding type of circuitry.

But the Law of Accelerating Returns tells us that evolution will not remain stuck at a dead end for very long. And indeed, evolution has found a way around the computational limitations of neural circuitry. Cleverly, it has created organisms that in turn invented a computational technology a million times faster than carbon-based neurons (which continue to get yet faster). Ultimately, the computing conducted on extremely slow mammalian neural circuits will be ported to a far more versatile and speedier electronic (and photonic) equivalent.

Yes, everyone, he’s talking about scanning and exactly replicating every neural connection and synapse in our brains, in a computer a billion or more times more powerful than the most powerful computers in existence today. "When will this happen?" Kurzweil asks, not figuratively. His guess is that by the year 2023 a personal computer costing $1,000 will have equal processing power to a human brain. From there it is only a short jump to being able to replicate all the connections of a single brain in a single computer.

In the second half of the twenty-first century, there will be a growing trend toward making this leap. Initially, there will be partial porting—replacing aging memory circuits, extending pattern-recognition and reasoning circuits through neural implants. Ultimately, and well before the twenty-first century is completed, people will port their entire mind file to the new thinking technology.

There will be nostalgia for our humble carbon-based roots, but there is nostalgia for vinyl records also. Ultimately, we did copy most of that analog music to the more flexible and capable world of transferable digital information. The leap to port our minds to a more capable computing medium will happen gradually but inexorably nonetheless.

As we port ourselves, we will also vastly extend ourselves. Remember that $1,000 of computing in 2060 will have the computational capacity of a trillion human brains. So we might as well multiply memory a trillion fold, greatly extend recognition and reasoning abilities, and plug ourselves into the pervasive wireless-communications network. While we are at it, we can add all human knowledge—as a readily accessible internal database as well as already processed and learned knowledge--- using the human type of distributed understanding.

Ultimate meaning? Immortality. That is, we’re not going to have to die.

Actually there won’t be mortality by the end of the twenty-first century. Not in the sense that we have known it. Not if you take advantage of the twenty-first century’s brain-porting technology. Up until now, our mortality was tied to the longevity of our hardware. When the hardware crashed, that was it. For many of our forebears, the hardware gradually deteriorated before it disintegrated....As we cross the divide to instantiate ourselves into our computational technology, our identity will be based on our evolving mind file. We will be software, not hardware.

And evolve it will. Today, our software cannot grow. It is stuck in a brain of a mere 100 trillion connections and synapses. But when the hardware is trillions of times more capable, there is no reason for our minds to stay so small. They can and will grow.

So that’s it. Ray Kurzweil, a respected scientist and inventor, is either off his rocker, or is foretelling a future that is assured and unavoidable, and will happen within the lifetime of many us reading this article.

Don’t believe it? Read the book. It’ll blow your mind. u

Click on a link below to read more about the book and possibly order it from Amazon.com

hardback.gif (51773 bytes)

Hardback verson

paperback.gif (6482 bytes)

Paperback version